Vista DUI Lawyer and Criminal Attorney Peter M. Liss

24 hour hotline
  • DUI / Felony DUI
    • Vista DUI Attorney
    • DMV Hearings
  • Domestic Violence
  • Sex Crimes
    • Sex Crime Defense
    • Child Molestation
    • Child Pornography
  • Traffic Offenses
    • Traffic Crimes
    • Hit and Run Accidents
    • No-License Driving
    • Reckless Driving
  • More Practice Areas
    • Juvenile Offenses
    • Violent Crime
      • The Three Strikes Law
      • Weapons Charges
    • Theft Defense
    • White Collar Crime
      • Fraud Charges
    • Drug Crimes
  • About
    • About Attorney Peter Liss
    • Contact Us
    • San Diego Office
    • Client Testimonials
    • Case Results
  • Resources
    • Law Blog
    • The Criminal Process
    • Hiring a Criminal Lawyer
  • English

The Concept of Imperfect Self Defense and When it Can be Used in Vista

May 18, 2018 Written by Jill Harness and Edited by Peter Liss

Last Updated on February 13, 2025

 

A man holding a gun to illustrate imperfect self defense definition and examples

Self-defense is considered a “perfect defense,” meaning you automatically qualify for a full acquittal if the defense succeeds. However, even with a top criminal attorney, it can be difficult to prove all of the requirements for self defense, particularly in a case involving murder. When it’s impossible to prove self defense in a murder case though, it may still be possible to argue that the defendant used “imperfect self defense” though, which will at least serve as a partial defense to the charges in the state of California.

How Self Defense Normally Works

For a lawyer to mount a successful argument for self defense, he must be able to show the client reasonably believed:

  1. they (or another person) were in danger
  2. that immediate force was required to stop the threat
  3. they did not use excessive force.

The last point can be particularly difficult to prove in murder cases where the victim was not armed or extremely violent, as you can only use deadly force to respond to a deadly threat. For self defense to justify homicide, you must be able to show that a reasonable person would have acted the same way.

Fortunately, if you can at least prove that you believed you needed to use deadly force, the charge can be reduced from murder to voluntary manslaughter —that’s what the “imperfect self defense” argument is.

Imperfect Self Defense Definition

This defense was first established under the 1979 California Supreme Court case of People Vs. Flannel, which is why sometimes called the Flannel Doctrine. For the defense to work, the jury must accept that someone believed:

  1. they were facing a deadly threat
  2. the only way to defend themselves was through the use of deadly force

When using this defense, it does not matter if either of those beliefs would be considered unreasonable to the average person. Because this concept only covers deadly force, this defense can only be used in murder cases.

For example, if you saw someone holding a knife up to someone else and yelling at them, and you shot them without saying a word, you might need to use this defense if it turned out that the person you killed was only rehearsing for a play.

How Does Imperfect Self Defense Work?

In a courtroom setting where you have been accused of murder, your attorney will present your case. The judge will provide the jury with the definition of true and imperfect self defense. If the jury accepts that a reasonable person would have believed their life was in immediate danger and they had no other way to protect themselves, you will be set free because you would have been found to have been acting in self defense. On the other hand, if the jury believed that you genuinely thought your life was in danger and the only way to protect yourself was to use deadly force but that an average person would not feel that way, you would be found guilty of voluntary manslaughter rather than murder under the Flannel Doctrine.

If you have any questions about what the difference between self defense and imperfect self defense is, please call (760) 643-4050 or (858) 486-3024 to speak with attorney Peter M. Liss.

Filed Under: Homicide, CRIMINAL DEFENSE, THE CA LEGAL SYSTEM, VIOLENT CRIMES, LEGAL PROCEDURES Tagged With: murder, manslaughter, homicide, violent crimes, defense of others, defenses, self defense, better understanding the law, court, deadly force

Call Today, I Can Help You

criminal justice attorney Peter M. Liss

The Experience You Need

I have been practicing law for over 40 years, and opened my own law firm in 1998, after serving as Assistant Supervising Public Defender for the Vista Public Defender’s Office. I have successfully defended hundreds of cases in my career, fighting charges ranging from drunk driving to capital murder.

Two Easy-to-Find Offices

My Vista offices are located just off the 78 freeway, directly across the street from the local courthouse and jail facility. For those further south, I have another office in Carmel Valley, off the 5 freeway and highway 56. Both offices offer free parking.

Call (760) 643-4050 Now

You can call my offices any time of day, every day to speak with a live person who can help you schedule a free initial consultation. If you have any questions, I return my calls promptly and courteously.

My Guarantee to You

Fight for your freedom without draining your wallet! I offer affordable rates and accept all major credit cards. Hablamos Espanol.

I’m available, let’s talk

My Practice Areas

I handle all types of misdemeanor and felony criminal cases in San Diego County, including:

  • Driving Under the Influence
    • DMV DUI License Hearings
  • Domestic Violence
    • Sex Crimes
    • Sexual Assault/Rape
  • Child Molestation
    • Child Pornography
  • White Collar Crimes
    • Fraud Cases
    • Identity Theft
    • Computer Crimes
    • Theft Crimes
    • Petty Theft
    • Grand Theft
    • Shoplifting
    • Robbery
  • Drug Charges
    • Drug DUI
    • Trafficking
  • Violent Crimes
    • Weapons Offenses
    • Assault
    • Homicide
    • Hate Crimes
    • Gang Crimes
    • Three Strikes Law
  • Criminal Traffic Offenses
    • Driving on a Suspended License
    • Hit and Run accidents
    • Reckless Driving
    • Vehicular Homicide
  • Juvenile Crime Defense
    • Truancy
    • Vandalism
    • Minor in Possession

Categories

  • THE CA LEGAL SYSTEM
  • CRIMINAL DEFENSE
  • DUI / FELONY DUI
    • Sentencing
    • Traffic Stops
  • DRIVING OFFENSES
  • DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
  • WHITE COLLAR CRIME
    • Computer Crimes
    • Fraud Charges
  • DRUG OFFENSES
  • VIOLENT CRIMES
    • Gang Crimes
    • Animal Abuse
    • Assault and Battery
    • Homicide
    • Kidnapping
    • Weapons Charges
  • SEX OFFENSES
    • Sharing Obscene Materials
    • Rape
    • Sex Crimes Involving Children
  • THEFT CRIMES
  • FAQs
  • FEDERAL CRIMES
  • HYPOTHETICAL SITUATIONS
  • JUVENILE CRIME
  • LEGAL PROCEDURES
  • SENTENCING ALTERNATIVES
  • DUI/ Felony DUI
  • Driving Offenses
  • Domestic Violence
  • White Collar Crimes
  • Theft Defense
  • Violent Crimes
  • Sex Offenses
  • Juvenile Crime
  • Drug Offenses
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
vista crimminal law logo
  • Attorney Peter M. Liss
  • (760) 643-4050
  • 380 S Melrose Drive #301 Vista, CA 92081

Copyright 2003, 2024 Peter M. Liss, Esq. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED


About the Legal Information on This Website

I rely on my experience as a top defense lawyer in my area to personally review all information on this site; however the information offered here should not substitute as legal advice. If you have been arrested or charged with a crime in Vista, please contact a qualified criminal defense attorney.

About Me Icon About Me Phone Call Icon Call Contact Icon Contact Email Icon Email